Skip to content
Back to the blog

Multi-location hospitality: a review management playbook for three or more properties

From three properties onward, review management becomes an organisational question: who replies to what, which tone applies, who decides on extortion or fake reviews. This playbook divides the tasks between head office and properties and shows what is known about response rates and guest expectations.

By Laurin Bassler, CEO & Co-Founder8 min read
Multi-location hospitality: a review management playbook for three or more properties

In short: Anyone running several hotels has to organise reviews differently from a single property: who replies to what, which tone of voice applies, who decides on extortion attempts or fake reviews. There are no reliable figures on the time required per property, so it is worth measuring it yourself. What is documented is that replies work: hotels that respond go on to receive more reviews and a slightly better rating. A Cornell study, however, found diminishing returns above a response rate of around 40%. This playbook divides the tasks between head office and the individual properties and proposes six indicators for a monthly report.

Figures as of November 2026.


What changes when the third property comes in

With one hotel, the owner or general manager often replies personally, knows many of the guests and writes replies on the side. With two properties it becomes routine, sometimes late. By the third property at the latest, the side task becomes an organisational question: who is responsible when management is not on site?

How many hours per property and week this takes has not been measured, neither for Switzerland nor in any international study we were able to check. So measure it yourself: for one month, record the time each property spends on replies, photos and follow-ups, then add it up across all properties. Only then will you know whether a central role is worth it.

This playbook is a proposal for how to divide the work. It is not based on a survey or on a customer case. The basics for a single property (four tasks, a weekly routine, costs) are in the guide Review management in Switzerland.


The multi-location trap

When a group keeps running its first properties with the same approach as a single hotel, this often happens:

  • Separate profiles, separate replies. Each property maintains its own photo pool, its own reply templates and its own answers to guest questions.
  • Growing workload. What the owner still handles personally at two properties ends up with the property manager at the third, who has other priorities, or it is left undone.
  • Inconsistent tone. If property A replies informally and property B formally, the group looks inconsistent as soon as a guest reads both profiles.
  • Uneven photo quality. Property A has a manager with a feel for marketing and a good gallery, property B uploads phone snapshots. It shows.
  • Unclear escalation. When a 1-star review arrives with an extortion attempt, nobody knows who decides: the property manager, head office or a lawyer.

The way out of this trap is not more attention but a clear division of tasks.


What belongs at head office

Three things belong at head office, whether that is the holding company, the management team or a dedicated reputation role.

1. Tone-of-voice guide

A written document that applies to all properties:

  • form of address (formal or informal; in Switzerland Sie, Du, Lei, vous)
  • stock phrases you want to avoid, and wording that suits your house (for example "you are right" or "that was on us")
  • language: reply in the language of the review, otherwise in a defined fallback language
  • length by review: longer for criticism than for brief praise
  • who signs the replies

The guide is a living document. Review it regularly, and at the latest when a new property joins.

2. Escalation rules

A clear table of who replies to which review:

ReviewWho replies
5 stars, no team member namedProperty manager, using a template as a framework
5 stars, praising a team memberProperty manager, personal reply
3 to 4 stars, specific criticismProperty manager, individual reply
1 to 2 stars, factual criticismProperty manager, head office reviews
1 to 2 stars, personal accusations against staffHead office
Suspected extortionHead office, with legal advice if needed, report to Google
Negative press coverageManagement, immediately

Deadlines: set a deadline for each row that your team can actually meet. There are no Swiss figures on what guests expect. In a 2026 US survey, 32% expect a reply by the following day and 81% within a week (BrightLocal, all industries).

Extortion: Google advises you not to pay or offer anything, to secure all evidence straight away and to report the case through a dedicated form (Google help).

Fake reviews are not a fringe issue: 12% of Swiss hotels notice fake reviews at least once a month, 48% in isolated cases. 54% are dissatisfied with the support they get from the platforms (distribution study 2025, covering Google, Booking.com and Tripadvisor). Head office decides who reports, so that cases are neither reported twice nor not at all.

3. Photo library

A central library with:

  • minimum quality standards (resolution, format, lighting)
  • mandatory categories per property (exterior, lobby, room categories, restaurant, spa if applicable, team)
  • a rule on the maximum age of a photo, and a fixed rhythm for professional shoots
  • team photos only with the consent of the people shown

What stays with each property

Not everything belongs at head office. Three things continue to run through the property, otherwise the personal touch and credibility are lost:

  1. Names in the team. Anyone mentioning a staff member by name in a reply needs to know who is meant. The property manager knows.
  2. Local knowledge. If a guest writes that the view from room 304 was fantastic, the reply needs to know that room 304 faces east. This knowledge cannot be centralised.
  3. Seasonal offers and events. Whatever only happens at one property is communicated by that property.

For winning new reviews, the same rule applies at every property: ask all guests in the same way, without pressure and without anything in return. Do not set numerical targets, neither for properties nor for staff, and do not pay bonuses per review. Google explicitly prohibits asking staff to solicit a specific number of reviews from customers, or reviews with specific content, such as reviews that name particular employees.


Six indicators for the monthly report

Without figures, review management remains an intention. Six indicators per property, collected once a month, are enough for an overview. We deliberately do not set targets, because there is no reliable basis for them.

  1. New reviews per month. Track it, but do not pass it on to the team as a target. Recency matters: in a US survey, 74% pay attention to reviews from the last three months (BrightLocal 2026).
  2. Average rating. The trend says more than any single value.
  3. Response rate. What it should be is not clearly established (see below).
  4. Response time. Measured against the deadlines in your escalation rules.
  5. Topics of criticism. Service, food, rooms, cleanliness: where does criticism cluster, and at which property?
  6. Special cases. Extortion attempts, suspected fakes, reported reviews and what came of the reports.

These six values fit on one page. More indicators rarely make the report wiser, fewer leave open where the group stands.

What is known about the response rate

The research does not point in one direction:

  • Hotels that respond to reviews go on to receive around 12% more reviews and a rating 0.12 stars higher (Proserpio and Zervas, Marketing Science 2017, data from Tripadvisor and Expedia).
  • A Cornell University study found diminishing revenue returns above a response rate of around 40%. Too many responses even performed worse than none at all. Ratings improved most with constructive responses to negative reviews (Anderson and Han, 2016, international, small sample).
  • In a US survey, 89% expect a reply to their review, and 80% would be more likely to choose a business that responds to all its reviews (BrightLocal 2026, all industries).

Our suggestion: always reply to criticism, and do so carefully. Reply to praise briefly and personally, never with the same formula.


Roles

In a group, three roles run in parallel:

  • Property manager: replies in the normal range (3 to 5 stars), photos to head office, local guest questions.
  • Head office: escalations, the tone-of-voice guide, photo standards and the monthly report to management. How much capacity this takes depends on the number of properties and reviews. Your own time measurement will show it. The task can sit in-house, with an agency or partly with software.
  • Management: decides in a crisis and reviews the situation once a quarter.

Where Trophy comes in

Trophy does not replace head office; it works with the team at each property. Every team member has their own card (NFC and QR code) that guests use to review directly on Google, and each review is credited to the person whose card the guest used. In the web app, staff see their winning streak, their rank in the team, their personal best and their next milestone, but not who is lagging behind. An AI drafts replies in the house's tone of voice and in the guest's language. For 1 to 2 stars, the owner sees the draft before it is sent.

Trophy is billed per location. From the second location there is a 10% discount, from the sixth 20%. Details are on packages and pricing. We do not yet have published figures for hotels; results from restaurants are on our cases page.

Book a demo →


Sources


Related reading

See Trophy in action

You've read howit works. Let us show you.

10 minutes. No sales pressure. You show us your venue, we show you Trophy.