Skip to content
Back to the blog

The 4.7 trap: are perfect ratings a disadvantage for hotels?

A 2017 Northwestern University study of online shops found that purchase likelihood typically peaks at 4.0 to 4.7 stars and falls as ratings approach 5.0. For hotels, this has not been measured. What the evidence does show, and how hotels build a review profile guests believe.

By Laurin Bassler, CEO & Co-Founder8 min read
The 4.7 trap: are perfect ratings a disadvantage for hotels?

In short: The so-called 4.7 trap goes back to a 2017 study by the Spiegel Research Center at Northwestern University. Using data from online shops, the researchers found that purchase likelihood typically peaks at an average rating between 4.0 and 4.7 stars and then falls as the rating approaches 5.0. The products studied included light bulbs, vitamins, athletic shoes and gifts, not hotels. Whether hotels with 4.9 stars get booked less than hotels with 4.6 has not been measured. What is documented for hotels is something else: a better rating supports higher rates, and guests look at recent reviews and at how a property handles criticism. The goal is therefore not a particular rating, but a profile that guests believe.

Figures as of November 2026.


Where the 4.7 trap comes from

The Spiegel Research Center at Northwestern University worked with the review provider PowerReviews to study how online reviews affect purchase behaviour. The report was published in June 2017. The data came from two online retailers covering 22 product categories and 111,460 items, and from an online retailer of high-end gifts with around 15.5 million page views.

The best-known finding: across product categories, purchase likelihood typically peaks at an average rating between 4.0 and 4.7 stars and then declines the closer the rating gets to 5.0. The best rating varied by category, but in no category was it 5.0. The researchers interpret this as shoppers seeing very high ratings as "too good to be true". The academic basis is an article by Maslowska, Malthouse and Bernritter in the International Journal of Advertising (2017).

Two further findings from the same report are useful for businesses:

  • Criticism builds credibility. Negative reviews make the reviews as a whole more credible. The authors advise not removing negative reviews, but monitoring them and responding to them.
  • People who are asked review differently. Buyers who were asked for a review by e-mail after their purchase gave 4.34 stars on average. Those who reviewed without being asked gave 3.89 stars on average and more often only one star. The authors explain this by very unhappy customers being more likely to write a review on their own initiative.

What this means for hotels

Before applying the finding to a hotel, three limitations matter:

  • Different products. The study looked at products such as light bulbs, hair care, athletic shoes, vitamins and gifts in online shops. Hotels, Google profiles and booking platforms were not part of it.
  • Buying is not booking. What was measured was the likelihood of a purchase in an online shop, not the booking of a hotel room.
  • No hotel threshold. We have not found any study showing that hotels get fewer bookings above a certain rating.

For hotels, other relationships are documented:

  • A better rating supports higher rates. In a Cornell University analysis, hotels could charge 11.2% more for one additional point on the five-point scale without losing occupancy or market share (USA, 2012).
  • Many guests set a minimum. In a 2026 US survey, 68% of consumers only use businesses with at least 4 stars (2025: 55%), and 31% only those with at least 4.5 stars. 47% won't use a business with fewer than 20 reviews (BrightLocal, all industries).
  • Swiss figures are old. The most recent public analysis of reviews of Swiss hotels dates from 2015. At that time they scored 81 out of 100 points on average (HES-SO Valais-Wallis and TrustYou, data from 2013 to 2015). There is no current Swiss average rating.

For hotels this means: a very high rating is not a documented disadvantage. What the studies show together is something else. Guests trust reviews more when there are many of them, when they are recent and when criticism is answered visibly and factually. In its own tips for businesses, Google writes that a mix of positive and negative feedback often feels more trustworthy.

What makes a rating look less credible

Three practices damage a profile's credibility and violate Google's policies.

Asking only happy guests

Telling the team to ask only guests who are likely to give five stars filters out criticism before it is written. Google explicitly prohibits businesses from discouraging negative reviews or selectively soliciting positive ones. Asking staff to collect a certain number of reviews is also not allowed.

Having critical reviews removed

You may flag a review if it violates Google's policies. Offering guests something in return for changing or removing a negative review, on the other hand, is prohibited. Offers that promise more are common: 20% of Swiss hotels receive offers for reputation management at least once a month, including grey-area offers such as bought reviews (HES-SO Valais-Wallis distribution study, reference year 2025).

Reviews from your own circle

Reviews of your own business by employees, former employees, relatives or business partners count as a conflict of interest at Google and are not allowed. Google removes fake reviews. It can also restrict a profile: for a period of time the profile cannot receive new reviews, existing reviews are temporarily unpublished, or the profile shows a warning that fake reviews were removed.

What helps instead

Ask all guests, all year round

A credible rating comes from many guests reviewing, not only the delighted and not only the annoyed. The finding from online retail shows why: people who write without being asked are more often unhappy. If you ask all guests in the same way, your rating reflects the full range of your guests.

Google recommends reminding guests to leave a review, for example with a link or a QR code. The limits: nothing in return, no pressure at the property, no requests for specific content and no review targets for the team. Because 74% in the US survey only care about reviews from the last three months, it pays to ask continuously rather than in one-off campaigns.

Reply to criticism

There is evidence that replies work:

  • Hotels that start replying to reviews receive around 12% more reviews afterwards and a rating that is 0.12 stars higher (Proserpio and Zervas, Marketing Science 2017).
  • In a 2019 Tripadvisor survey, 89% of users said that a thoughtful reply to a negative review improves their impression of the business. This is self-reported, not measured behaviour.

A good reply to a three-star review picks up the specific point, explains factually and invites the guest back. The same applies to a one-star review, with even more calm. Google advises replying politely, honestly, personally and promptly, and never sharing private information. Unanswered criticism leaves the next guest with only one side of the story. You will find templates in our reply templates.

No target rating

The research does not support any particular rating that a hotel should aim for. Trying to steer the rating quickly leads to the practices described above. The rating is the result of the work done in the hotel. If you ask all guests and reply honestly, you have a rating that guests believe.

Where Trophy comes in

Trophy is not designed to push your rating up. Every team member has a personal card with NFC and a QR code through which all guests reach the Google review in the same way. There is no filter that keeps criticism away from Google. The review is attributed to the person whose card the guest used. On their phone, each person sees their winning streak, their rank in the team and their next milestone, but not who is falling behind. An AI writes the replies in your hotel's tone of voice and in the guest's language. For reviews with one or two stars, you see the draft before it is sent.

More on this: How Trophy works and For hotels.

Book a demo

FAQ

Do hotels with 4.9 stars get fewer bookings than hotels with 4.6 stars? That has not been shown. The study behind this claim (Spiegel Research Center, Northwestern University, 2017) looked at online shops. There, purchase likelihood typically peaked at 4.0 to 4.7 stars. There is no comparable measurement for hotels.

What Google rating should a hotel aim for? The research does not support a target rating. In a 2026 US survey, 68% of consumers only use businesses with at least 4 stars. More important than a particular number are many, recent and genuine reviews.

Do negative reviews hurt a hotel? Not necessarily. According to the Spiegel study, negative reviews make the reviews as a whole more credible, and Google writes that a mix of positive and negative feedback often feels more trustworthy. What matters is a factual reply.

May a hotel ask only happy guests for a review? No. Google prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews or discouraging negative ones. Ask all guests in the same way, with nothing in return and without pressure.

Sources


Related reading

See Trophy in action

You've read howit works. Let us show you.

10 minutes. No sales pressure. You show us your venue, we show you Trophy.